Updated November 17, 2009
EPA Employees Silenced for Criticizing Cap and Trade
- FOXNews.com
When Zabel and Williams released a video on the Internet expressing their concerns over the Obama administration’s plans to use a cap and trade program to fight climate change, they were told to keep it to themselves.
Laurie Williams and husband Alan Zabel worked as lawyers for the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, in its San Francisco office for more than 20 years, and they know more about climate change than most politicians. But when the couple released a video on the Internet expressing their concerns over the Obama administration’s plans to use cap-and-trade legislation to fight climate change, they were told to keep it to themselves.
Williams and Zabel oppose cap and trade -- a controversial government allowance program in which companies are issued emissions limits, or caps, which they can then trade -- as a means to fight climate change.
On their own time, Williams and Zabel made a video expressing these opinions.
VIDEO: EPA Employees Speak Out Against Cap and Trade
"Cap-and-trade with offsets provides a false sense of progress and puts money in the pockets of investors," Zabel said in the video. "We think that these restrictions might not be constitutional," he said.
Their bosses in San Francisco approved the effort by Williams and Zabel to release the tape, but after an editorial they wrote appeared in the Washington Post, EPA Director Lisa Jackson ordered the pair to remove the video or face disciplinary action.
Specifically, the administration's chief environmental official did not want Williams or Zabel mentioning their four decades with the EPA -- time spent studying cap and trade.
"The people who understand the problems with the cap and trade with offsets bill are not being heard," Williams told Fox News.
The EPA issued a statement saying it welcomes free expression provided employees adhere to ethics rules. The agency reportedly doesn't object to the content of the video but requires Williams and Zabel to make it clearer that they are speaking for themselves and not the EPA.
But some Republicans on the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee want an investigation into what – if any -- regulations Zabel and Williams violated.
Critics argue the action contradicts the president's support for open government.
"It's censorship," Jeff Ruch, Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, told Fox News.
"If the Obama administration believes in transparency it is precisely in these cases they need to prove it."
Fox Nation
-
Captain America: Tea Parties Dangerous, Racist
February 08, 2010 62 comments
-
Ayatollah: Iran Anniversary 'Punch' Will Stun West
February 08, 2010 45 comments
-
After Buying Spree, China Owns Stakes In Top U.S. Firms
February 08, 2010 23 comments
-
Meghan McCain Rails Against Tea Parties
February 08, 2010 128 comments
-
'Red Eye' Ratings Top CNN Prime Time
February 08, 2010 8 comments
-
Officers to Retrieve Edwards Sex Tape
February 08, 2010 7 comments
-
Obama Wants Ban on School Snack Vending Machines
February 08, 2010 54 comments
-
Al Gore Snowman Contest
February 08, 2010 12 comments
-
Rep. Kennedy Calls Sen. Scott Brown a 'Joke'
February 08, 2010 50 comments
-
Jessica Alba: Marriage Is a Load of Crap
February 08, 2010 66 comments
Most Commented
-
Why is the White House Still Attacking Fox News?
October 19, 2009 2,512 comments
-
Should Justice Investigate ACORN?
September 10, 2009 1,523 comments
-
Did 'Curb' and HBO Cross the Line?
October 28, 2009 1,489 comments
-
Navy SEALs Charged -- What Effect Does It Have on the Troops?
November 25, 2009 1,381 comments
-
Do You Agree With Decision to Release Lockerbie Bomber?
August 20, 2009 1,296 comments
-
Donald Luskin: Republicans and the Populist Temptation
February 08, 2010
-
McGurn: Bush Was Right, Says Obama
February 08, 2010
-
Cheney's Revenge
February 08, 2010
-
The Summit Gambit
February 08, 2010
-
James Copland: How the Plaintiffs Bar Bought the Senate
February 08, 2010
-
Peter Calvocoressi: writer, publisher and lawyer
February 09, 2010
-
Getting into university is not The X Factor . . .
February 08, 2010
-
A bully and liar who played the system
February 08, 2010
-
This beard thing is growing from the roots up
February 08, 2010
-
They’re all ignoring political climate change
February 08, 2010
-
The Road to Serfdom: Public Servants Our Masters?
February 09, 2010
-
Imprisoning Kids
February 08, 2010 61 comments
-
You Fund BS Artist
February 08, 2010 7 comments
-
Media Ignore Health Gains
February 07, 2010 11 comments
-
Spiro T. Obama
February 06, 2010 93 comments



recommend

Subscribe to Comments
