Updated November 17, 2009
EPA Employees Silenced for Criticizing Cap and Trade
- FOXNews.com
When Zabel and Williams released a video on the Internet expressing their concerns over the Obama administration’s plans to use a cap and trade program to fight climate change, they were told to keep it to themselves.
Laurie Williams and husband Alan Zabel worked as lawyers for the Environmental Protection Agency, EPA, in its San Francisco office for more than 20 years, and they know more about climate change than most politicians. But when the couple released a video on the Internet expressing their concerns over the Obama administration’s plans to use cap-and-trade legislation to fight climate change, they were told to keep it to themselves.
Williams and Zabel oppose cap and trade -- a controversial government allowance program in which companies are issued emissions limits, or caps, which they can then trade -- as a means to fight climate change.
On their own time, Williams and Zabel made a video expressing these opinions.
VIDEO: EPA Employees Speak Out Against Cap and Trade
"Cap-and-trade with offsets provides a false sense of progress and puts money in the pockets of investors," Zabel said in the video. "We think that these restrictions might not be constitutional," he said.
Their bosses in San Francisco approved the effort by Williams and Zabel to release the tape, but after an editorial they wrote appeared in the Washington Post, EPA Director Lisa Jackson ordered the pair to remove the video or face disciplinary action.
Specifically, the administration's chief environmental official did not want Williams or Zabel mentioning their four decades with the EPA -- time spent studying cap and trade.
"The people who understand the problems with the cap and trade with offsets bill are not being heard," Williams told Fox News.
The EPA issued a statement saying it welcomes free expression provided employees adhere to ethics rules. The agency reportedly doesn't object to the content of the video but requires Williams and Zabel to make it clearer that they are speaking for themselves and not the EPA.
But some Republicans on the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee want an investigation into what – if any -- regulations Zabel and Williams violated.
Critics argue the action contradicts the president's support for open government.
"It's censorship," Jeff Ruch, Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility, told Fox News.
"If the Obama administration believes in transparency it is precisely in these cases they need to prove it."
Fox Nation
-
Health Care 101: What happens if the bill passes
March 15, 2010
-
Lady Gaga Video Banned by MTV?
March 15, 2010 8 comments
-
Seinfeld Mocks Massa on 'SNL'
March 15, 2010 3 comments
-
Bachmann: Obama First 'Post-American' President, Compares Him to Chavez
March 15, 2010 45 comments
-
Left-Wing 'Green Zone' Bombs at Box Office
March 15, 2010 26 comments
-
Horrific Details of Edwards Sex Tape Released
March 15, 2010 8 comments
-
Moody's Warns Obama on AAA Credit Rating
March 15, 2010 28 comments
-
Calvin Klein's XXX Ad Campaign
March 15, 2010 12 comments
-
Justice Stevens, 90, Hints at Retirement
March 15, 2010
Most Commented
-
Did Health Care Summit Accomplish Anything?
February 25, 2010 1,452 comments
-
Health Care Summit: How’s It Going?
February 24, 2010 1,270 comments
-
Was Tiger's Apology Good Enough for You?
February 19, 2010 1,255 comments
-
Does the 'Reconciliation' Gambit Make You Angry?
March 03, 2010 1,242 comments
-
Is Democrats' Health Care Reform Legislation Doomed?
March 10, 2010 1,144 comments

-
Burlingame and Joscelyn: Gitmo's Indefensible Lawyers
March 14, 2010
-
O'Grady: Democrats and Haiti Telecom
March 15, 2010
-
Higgins and Conway: Swing Districts Oppose Health Reform
March 14, 2010
-
Obama's Turn Against Israel
March 14, 2010
-
The Hedge Fund Wars
March 14, 2010


-
Who can we trust to look after our money?
March 14, 2010
-
Don’t be sniffy about personality politics
March 14, 2010
-
Adonis strategy on drink-driving is the absolute limit
March 14, 2010
-
Full marks to Four Marks for taking a stand
March 14, 2010
-
We climate scientists are not ecofanatics
March 14, 2010

-
Pelosi's Pampered Artists
March 15, 2010
-
Chump Change
March 14, 2010
-
Free Trade Watch
March 12, 2010 15 comments
-
Fiscal Responsibility is No Fun
March 12, 2010 10 comments
-
Pigs at the Trough
March 12, 2010 9 comments

-
Greece's Problem? The New York Times
March 09, 2010 3 comments
-
Tired of Bailout Nation?
March 05, 2010 46 comments
-
The Case for Medical Malpractice Reform
March 03, 2010 32 comments
-
Another AIG Magical Mystery Tour
March 01, 2010 3 comments
-
New York Times Whiffs on Greece, Again
February 26, 2010 12 comments

-
We don't know how to fix bad schools
March 15, 2010
-
The troll in the closet
March 15, 2010
-
The real Rielle Hunter
March 15, 2010
-
Rod Dreher in USA Today
March 15, 2010
-
Law at the Jesus Creed: David Opderbeck
March 15, 2010



recommend

Subscribe to Comments
